_edited.png)
Real Ingredients. No Compromises.
Most bakeries "go sugar-free" with honey, maple syrup, dates, or agave. Here's the problem: those ingredients spike blood sugar the same way cane sugar does. They're natural — but not low-glycemic. That's not good enough for our customers, and it's not good enough for us.
At Purely Coastal Creations, diabetic-friendly means low-glycemic from start to finish. We bake with allulose, erythritol, and monk fruit — sweeteners that don't raise blood sugar the way conventional sugar does. Our specialty flours (almond, coconut) replace high-carb wheat where the recipe calls for it. Every batch is made to order, small-batch, in our Port Saint Lucie kitchen.
Because specialty ingredients cost more than conventional ones, diabetic-friendly items carry a +30% upcharge over our standard pricing. We're upfront about that because you deserve to know what goes into your food — and why it's worth it.
Everything You Love, Made for Your Life
You shouldn't have to sit out the birthday cake. You shouldn't have to skip the holiday table. Our diabetic-friendly line covers every occasion — so you're never choosing between your health and the celebration.
Custom Cakes
A custom diabetic-friendly cake built for a Port Saint Lucie birthday, anniversary, or milestone — layered, decorated, and made to your design.
We consult with you on flavor and design before we bake a single crumb.
Please allow 14 days for custom designs; 4 days for standard orders.
_e.png)
Decorated Cookies
Our hand-decorated cookies are one of our most requested diabetic-friendly items. Birthdays, holidays, corporate gifts, thank-yous — each cookie is decorated by hand and made with low-glycemic sweeteners. Available in sets sized for every occasion
Cupcakes
Individual, perfectly portioned, and every bit as indulgent as the original. Cupcakes are available in a range of flavors — ask us what's baking this week or place a custom order for your event.
Cake Pops
The festive favorite, reimagined without the sugar spike. Our cake pops use the same low-glycemic approach as every item in this line — rich, satisfying, and made to share. Ideal for parties, gift boxes, and event favors.
Holiday Pies
Thanksgiving and Christmas at the table — without compromising the dessert. Our diabetic-friendly holiday pie line brings back the flavors of the season: classic, comforting, and made with ingredients that keep the celebration where it belongs.
Available seasonally. Pre-order early — holiday pies sell out fast. Weekly pre-orders close Thursdays at 8pm for Saturday Pickup or Delivery.
_edit.png)
How Ordering Works
Order online at purelycoastalcreations.com, or reach us by phone or text at 772-775-4949, or email info@purelycoastalcreations.com.
Weekly pre-orders close Thursdays at 8pm. Saturday porch pickup is available in Port Saint Lucie (1629 SE North Blackwell Drive — near Melaleuca and Green River Parkway). Select your pickup time slot at checkout.
Local delivery is available within 20 miles of Port Saint Lucie (34952). The first 10 miles are free. A $7.95 delivery fee applies beyond 10 miles.
Custom cakes require 14 days minimum for a custom design and 4 days for a standard order. All other items are available with 48-hour notice.
Your Neighbors Already Know
Port Saint Lucie has one of the most health-conscious communities on the Treasure Coast — and every October, that community grows when our neighbors return from up north for the winter. We see you. We bake for you.
Every order is made fresh, made to order, and never frozen. And when you order from Purely Coastal Creations, your delivery comes from us personally — the owners, not a driver, not a service. That's a different kind of bakery.
Questions We Hear All the Time
Are your diabetic-friendly items actually low-glycemic, or just "natural sugar"? Actually low-glycemic. We use allulose, erythritol, and monk fruit — not honey, maple syrup, dates, or agave. Those natural sweeteners still spike blood sugar. Ours don't, and that's the whole point.
Can I order a custom diabetic-friendly cake for a birthday or special occasion? Yes. A full custom consultation is part of every custom cake order. You tell us the design, flavors, and occasion. We handle the rest. Please plan for at least 14 days for a fully custom design.
Do you offer diabetic-friendly holiday pies?
Yes — we offer diabetic-friendly pies for Thanksgiving and Christmas. These are seasonal and sell out before the holiday, so pre-order early. Weekly pre-orders close Thursdays at 8pm for Saturday Pickup or Delivery.
Why are diabetic-friendly items priced higher?
Specialty low-glycemic flours and sweeteners cost significantly more than conventional ingredients. The +30% upcharge reflects that reality. We believe transparency is part of the service.
Do you ship, or is this pickup and delivery only? We deliver locally within 20 miles of Port Saint Lucie (34952 area), and offer Saturday porch pickup at our home kitchen. We do not ship perishable baked goods out of the local area. This is a Florida cottage food operation — everything is made fresh to order, not shipped nationwide.
Ready to Place Your Order?
We bake every item fresh, to your order, for your occasion.
Weekly pre-orders close Thursdays at 8pm for Saturday Pickup or Delivery.